|
HBO’s popular series “The Sopranos”
features Tony Soprano, an Italian-American gangster bedeviled
by the contradictions between his violent livelihood and
All-American home life. In one memorable early episode,
Tony takes his college-bound teenage daughter to visit
a variety of potential institutions, while — unbeknownst
to her — he tracks down and murders a blood rival.
This tension between his domestic aspirations and his
brutal job as mob boss leads him to the psychiatrist’s
couch, where the lovely Herr Doctor attempts to treat
his panic attacks by getting him to look at the moral
contradictions of his life.
At the risk of lending too much intellectual credence
to a television entertainment, it has always struck me
that the show’s popularity was based on the fact
that Tony Soprano is our Everyman. His contradictions
are our contradictions, insofar as our privileged lifestyle
is enabled by a brutal foreign policy financed with our
tax dollars. To choose one easy example, our “cheap
oil” is not really cheap at all, not if you count
the unseen costs (human, environmental, and financial)
of maintaining a global military presence tasked with
keeping those foreign oil spigots flowing.
On some level, most U.S. citizens are aware of their personal
complicity in the crimes of our rogue government. Most
of us avoid looking at our own responsibility for the
atrocities committed in our name because such introspection
is uncomfortable. Yet this reluctance to confront such
unpleasant truths has largely hog-tied the American peace
movement, rendering it helpless in the face of a regime
determined to wage war wherever it sees fit.
I rarely hear any discussion of tactics in the Left press:
How can we stop the Bush/Cheney juggernaut? Instead, Beltway
myopia keeps political pundits focused on whether or not
a Democratic congress will confront the White House. When
writers and activists do call for mass action by the grassroots,
it tends to be of the acquiescent variety: another march
on Washington, another candlelight vigil, or — at
its most militant — a carefully choreographed civil
disobedience.
Yet the best way to shut down state-sponsored terrorism
would be to cut off its funding at the source. In the
United States, this would require a massive campaign of
tax resistance, a tactic that no one in the anti-war movement
seems willing to take seriously yet. When I point out
the hypocrisy of marching against the war while continuing
to finance it, I’m usually met with an uncomfortable
silence, followed by the confession that the personal
risks are too high.
This cowardice — for I can think of no more accurate
word to describe our fear of taking action — corrodes
the good intentions of the peace movement. At worst, this
contradiction between words and action creates the same
psychological tension that drove Tony Soprano to seek
therapy: We want all the privileges of American imperialism,
while demanding moral absolution for the crimes that are
committed with our tax dollars. It should be obvious that
we can’t have it both ways.
Technically speaking, it’s very easy to opt out
of the tax game. Simply fill out a new W-4 and check the
box on Line 7, declaring yourself “exempt”
(morally). Your payroll department will be obliged to
stop deducting income tax immediately. What happens after
that is up to you. Some, like myself, will broadcast their
strategy in the hopes that others join in. Others will
choose to be more discrete.
The IRS will eventually contact you. I got a call last
year from a tax agent who began asking me about my income
and expenses. At first I was reluctant to divulge any
information, but eventually I realized where he was headed.
He crunched the numbers and declared that I was “uncollectible”
— probably the first time I was ever happy to be
poor! Needless to say, the more money you earn, the greater
the risks.
The actual number of people sent to jail for this “crime”
is minuscule. Somewhere down the road, you might have
your wages garnished. To learn more about the consequences
of tax resistance, you can contact the War Resisters League
at www.warresisters.org.
In my mind, however, the overriding question was never:
what happens if I do this? The most important question
was always: What happens if I don’t do this? What
happens to the Iraqi people if I continue to finance our
occupation? What happens to my soul if I continue to fund
something I abhor?
Jess Grant is a Seattle-based songwriter, non-profit
administrator, and leader of the world’s only
musical tribute to Joan Jett, Jett City.
|