November 24, 2010
Vol: 17 No: 47


Disappearing acts in Pioneer Square

By Jim Gupta-Carlson / Contributing Writer

Documenting Pioneer Square, a photo essay by Jim Gupta-Carlson

Occidental Park was empty. I was taken by the way the sun was shining through the fall leaves in the trees, patterns of brown leaves on the ground. After focusing my camera towards the end the park, a bride and groom and their photographers literally bopped in for a few photos and then left. This was the story of Pioneer Square in a way: at times lonely and desolate, but then all of a sudden, a burst of happiness and joy.

Photo by Jim Gupta-Carlson / Contributing Writer

This photo is from early evening Christmas Eve. He walked right up to me and stood in front of my camera and read from; his "Book of knowledge" (which I have at my desk). He may have been a veteran as he had all the signs of a traumatic brain injury. His eyes went in different directions regardless of where he was looking and his nose was running and he drooled. We "talked" for about 10 minutes and then he shook my hand and said; We've met. I'm Avery. It was very weird, because while he read his book I felt like I'd met him before.

Photo by Jim Gupta-Carlson / Contributing Writer

Printer-Friendly Version

Like it? Share it!


About one year ago, I began a 30-day journey as a documentary photographer and diarist of Pioneer Square. Usually I would take the number 3 bus from my home in the Central District to Pioneer Square, carrying my trusty old Pentax and a few rolls of film. My goal was to shoot a roll every day for 30 days. I ended up shooting about 45 rolls over about 50 days. The project took longer partly because I ran out of money, causing me to wait to buy film, and partly because I started to run short on energy. It is hard to stay excited about a project when you are in the company of one.

In some ways, the extended project became a blessing. It gave me an opportunity to visit Pioneer Square at 4 a.m. on the morning after Thanksgiving, on Black Friday, after the outpouring of gratitude and generosity and before most retail stores opened for the holiday shopping season. My wife Himanee and I had gone shopping downtown earlier in the morning—Old Navy opened at 3 a.m.—with $50 each to spend, which we both felt was a blessing considering our financial condition. Downtown was already crowded.

Pioneer Square, by contrast, was almost silent, the streets lonely. A curious kind of lonely, because there were people out and about. For instance, the Union Gospel Mission was full and was turning people away for the night. Across the street, homeless people sleeping on the sidewalk disappeared into the landscape. And so my wife and I walked. We met the same two gentlemen twice within the hour, both trying to stay awake long enough to make it to the Millionair Club for breakfast and a chance for work. Each time we shared a cigarette and wished each other a happy Thanksgiving.

When I did this project, it was such an emotional experience: There was so much pain and loneliness at night. Some people had nowhere to go, no one to talk to. But in the morning, when food was offered in Occidental Park or City Hall Park, it really returned the humanity to a neighborhood that had seemed desolate and empty.

My method for shooting urban life is to simply shoot. I shoot every image as though it were a portrait. A photograph should capture the spirit and essence of its subject, whatever it is. I often frame my images to be dominated by the ground or the street. The ground to me symbolizes the life that is, has been, and will be a spiritual part of our communities and neighborhoods. Just after parking our old Volvo under the viaduct on Christmas Eve, I set up to shoot a building across the street. The old building, the streetlights and alleyway shared the spirit of those who built it, lived in it and rested against it. Just after focusing and framing, a hooded man appeared. He did not look well, physically or mentally. He pulled out a notebook that he called his “Book of Knowledge” and started to read from it, mostly incoherent, but all the while, I felt like I knew him. After he read, he turned to me and said, “We’ve met. I’m Avery.” I started to think we really had.

Christmas Eve night was an emotionally overwhelming and physically demanding exercise. My wife and I are athletes, have run many marathons and, being from the Midwest, know real cold weather. We brought plenty of warm clothes, and money for coffee and drinks when we needed to go inside. I think the overnight low was near 40 degrees. Standing on cold pavement for hour upon hour, however well dressed we were, became mind-numbingly miserable. Yet we saw hundreds of people sleeping on sidewalks because the shelters were full. That night, there was wailing and crying, there were groups of teenagers roaming and yelling, and there was this feeling again of great loneliness—in spite of the multitudes of people out.

As the skies lightened, the energy changed to one of activity and anticipation. At Occidental and City Hall Parks, trucks and cars were arriving. Thousands of people were gathering from all directions. There were smiles, handshakes and steam from hot coffee and hot soup. Materially, there were food and blankets on Christmas morning for those in need. Spiritually, there was shared breath.

Today, I write from a position of changed circumstances. I am living in upstate New York, finishing my B.A. at SUNY-Empire State College, where my wife began a position as an assistant professor in April. We are hoping soon to close a deal on a house built in the 1840s that comes with three acres of land and a barn. I recently had surgery for a herniated disk, and while the pain is intense, I am able to relax knowing that the health benefits that accompany my wife’s job will not make me suffer financially.

A year ago, the story was much different.

We felt how many people felt—and feel



YES, the Revolutionary EDAR, a Shopping Cart Becomes a Housing Start Before anyones decides to Hobo UP and Ride the Rails, check out an EDAR, (Everyone Deserves a Roof). I did and I must say this Hobo Condo has everything except power and water. The EDAR, is a four-wheeled, tent-like home that's designed to be waterproof, sturdy and mobile. Each unit is equipped with a mattress and a sleeping bag for comfort. An integral braking system keeps the unit from rolling away, and a padlock is included to prevent theft. At night, the EDAR unit easily hinges out and down to Night Mode in less than 30 seconds, becoming a sleeping unit. The metal and wood base has a mattress and military-grade canvas cover, providing a robust tent-like shelter. The unit is flame-retardant, waterproof, windproof and helps protect from the elements. This reengineering of the cardboard box by Eric Lindeman and Jason Zasa was done at Pasadena Art Center College. The concept is the brain child local philanthropist Peter Samuelson. This also a big break for supermarkets and customers. I often find all the carts left are catawampus. Since I'm a 99ER and this is winter the EDAR is my new first choice before I HOBO UP on the Rail Highway in summer. Artist Country Carl dot com of the 99ers New Depression Blues Video,

A Homeless Solution | submitted on 11/28/2010, 7:47pm

Thank you for this moody study in light and shadow. Pioneer Square has always been an important location in the story of this place. Native Duwamish people lived here during the city's early days before being displaced by settlers, and immigrants have made millions from this rich port. During the Depression a Hooverville grew nearby. Gay bars lined the streets for many years in the pre Stonewall era,. Here is where there has seemingly long been a sharp and shattering contrast between the haves and the have nots,. I spent alot of time here in the 60s, and I can say that the marginalization of the poor, the lesbians and gays and immigrants drew people together in a rare and fascinating way. In recent times the area has been populated by many homeless people. Your photographs illuminate beautifully the presence of human beings who are often made invisible to the larger community. We need to reflect on the ways that we treat one another, and just what sort of society we wish for.Your words clarify your intentions. I think this is vital and important work for our society, and I hope that you continue. Thank you Jim Gupta-Carlson! Thank you Real Change!

KiKi | submitted on 12/03/2010, 2:53am

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.

Search Our Archives


Nominate a Vendor of the Week